How it works
How an ESMSEF review works
Every case follows the same documented path, whoever submits it, from contractual designation to a written determination.

The review process
Five steps, every case
- 01
Designation
The provider and payor contractually agree to use ESMSEF as their independent external review organization.
- 02
Submission
The case and its medical documentation are submitted to ESMSEF through a secure channel and checked for completeness.
- 03
Assignment
The case is assigned to qualified reviewers with no conflict of interest relative to the case.
- 04
Review
Certified coders, registered nurses and board-certified physicians review the case against nationally recognized criteria and coding guidelines, as the issue requires.
- 05
Determination
A fair, unbiased written determination, substantiated by the documentation submitted, is issued timely.
Our standards
What every review is held to
These standards do not change based on who submits the case.
No conflict of interest
Reviewers are assigned with no conflict of interest relative to the case.
Active-practice physicians
Clinical decisions by board-certified physicians currently in active practice.
Recognized criteria
Nationally recognized medical criteria and coding guidelines.
Grounded in the record
Every determination is substantiated by the documentation submitted.
Timely response
Generally 30–40 days from receipt of all materials.
Confidentiality
All medical information reviewed is kept confidential.
How long does a determination take?
Decisions are generally rendered in 30–40 days, and under 45 days, from receipt of all requested materials.
Who decides which review organization handles a dispute?
The contract between the provider and the payor. Both parties agree in advance to use an independent external review organization; without that provision there is no defined path for an external review.
Who reviews each case?
It depends on the issue. Questions involving a clinical decision are decided by a board-certified physician currently in active practice, in the same or a similar specialty as the issue under review. Coding questions are reviewed by certified coders, with a physician involved when a clinical decision is at issue. Registered nurses review medical records against nationally recognized criteria.
Do both parties receive the determination?
Yes. The written determination is shared with both the provider and the payor.
