All resources

Resources

Internal vs. external appeal: what is the difference?

Who reviews each, how independent each is, and when to move to external review.

Short answer

An internal appeal is reconsidered by the same organization that made the original decision. An external appeal is reviewed by an independent organization with no affiliation to either party, which issues a written determination both sides can rely on.

Last reviewed October 2026 · ESMSEF

Internal appeal

An internal appeal asks the organization that made a decision to reconsider it. It is usually the first step in resolving a dispute, and it is reviewed by that organization’s own staff or contracted reviewers.

External appeal

An external appeal moves the dispute outside both organizations. An independent review organization, designated in advance by contract, reviews the medical documentation and issues the determination.

The key differences

  • Who reviews it: the original decision-maker, or an unaffiliated organization
  • Independence: an external reviewer has no stake in the outcome and is screened for conflict of interest
  • Timing: external review generally follows an internal process that has not resolved the dispute
  • The result: a written determination from a neutral party, shared with both sides

Common questions

Common questions

Do you have to complete an internal appeal first?

Generally an external appeal follows an internal process that has not resolved the dispute, but the exact requirements depend on the contract between the provider and the payor.

Who performs external appeals for providers and payors?

An independent review organization designated in their contract, such as ESMSEF.