All resources

Resources

What is an Independent Review Organization (IRO)?

What an IRO is, why independence matters, and who performs the review.

Short answer

An Independent Review Organization (IRO) is an organization with no affiliation to either party in a healthcare payment dispute. It reviews the case and issues an impartial, written determination based on the medical record and nationally recognized criteria.

Last reviewed October 2026 · ESMSEF

Why independence matters

When a provider and a payor disagree about payment for care, a decision made by either party’s own staff is a decision one side has an interest in. A decision made by an unaffiliated organization is one both sides can rely on.

That is the role of an IRO: it does not work for the provider, and it does not work for the payor.

What an IRO reviews

Disputes typically involve one or more of the following:

  • Medical necessity of an admission or service
  • Level of care
  • Readmissions
  • Experimental or investigational services
  • Coding and DRG assignment
  • High-cost (cost outlier) claims

Who performs the review

Reviews are performed by qualified clinical and coding professionals who are screened for conflict of interest on every case. At ESMSEF, clinical decisions are made by board-certified physicians currently in active practice, in the same or a similar specialty as the issue under review, and coding questions are reviewed by certified coders.

How IROs are held accountable

Accreditation is the main external check on an IRO. ESMSEF has been URAC-accredited as an Independent Review Organization since 2013 and is a member of NAIRO, the National Association of Independent Review Organizations.

Common questions

Common questions

Is an IRO the same as a payor’s internal review?

No. An internal review is performed by the organization that made the original decision. An IRO is a separate organization with no affiliation to either party.

Is ESMSEF an Independent Review Organization?

Yes. ESMSEF is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit IRO that has performed independent external review since 1991 and has been URAC-accredited since 2013.